A Vulnerability Disclosure Gone Wrong

An example of a vulnerability disclosure gone wrong…


I debated mentioning the company, but will resist.  While making a contribution through a well known payment processing app, I discovered a vulnerability.  It was an OWASP top-10 vulnerability and was discoverable while doing nothing more than using the app as a normal’ish user would.  Okay, true, my wife probably would not have discovered it. But, that’s simply because she would not have known what she was looking for.

My attempt of responsible disclosure

Read the email thread from the bottom up…

InfoSec professionals beware

If an origination does not have a disclosure policy/program/process/contact/etc., do NOT attempt to disclose a discovered vulnerability.  There’s nothing to gain, but everything to lose.  It’s just not worth it.  If the organization is too immature to have a disclosure policy or process, they are likely going to handle a disclosure immaturely as well.

Businesses: Please post a disclosure policy/process

All businesses need to make sure you have created and posted a responsible disclosure process, contact information, and/or listed your org with a bug bounty program.  There are so many options and places to do this.  Here are a few examples, all taken straight from https://www.owasp.org/index.php/Vulnerability_Disclosure_Cheat_Sheet:

  • Create security contacts: typical security@, abuse@, noc@ (RFC2142) or public CERT.
  • Create and post a vulnerability disclosure policy/page
  • Sign-up with a bug bounty program. Example platforms : hackerone, bugcrowd, synack, bountyfactory.io…
  • Create a security.txt file on your website. More info: https://securitytxt.org/

If you have any doubts on what to do, please reach out to me; I’ll be more than glad to offer assistance.  Most of us disclosing vulnerabilities are not “bad” people wanting to cause you harm.  We’re here to help make you more secure!

Original Source: https://twitter.com/redeemedHacker/status/1029950560517148672

Schedule a no obligation consultation with PEN Consultants today! Information & Cybersecurity Testing - Penetration Testing, Red Teaming, Vulnerability Scanning and Assessment services for Apps, Web Apps, Network, Wireless, and more!

Categories: Blog